Podcasts

Rangers: Jonny McFarlane compares Malik Tillman with Charlie Adam

|

Journalist Jonny McFarlane has compared divisive Rangers forward Malik Tillman with former player Charlie Adam. 

Despite the 20-year-old netting the winner for Giovanni van Bronckhorst’s men in their midweek outing – a 1-0 Scottish Premiership win over Hearts – his work ethic still came in for plenty of scrutiny after the game.

Indeed, his manager has even told the press that Tillman needs to work on taking more ‘responsibility’ in games in terms of what he can bring to the team defensively.

Regardless of that, the Rangers youngster certainly seems to have plenty of potential, having come through at the youth level with German giants Bayern Munich.

When discussing Tillman on the Rangers Review YouTube channel, McFarlane said that he has plenty of quality but a lack of basics reminds him of former player Adam.

Will Malik Tillman come good for Rangers?

Yes

Yes

No

No

TIF Thoughts on Malik Tillman and Rangers…

Backing up what McFarlane has said, a 2009 article in Bleacher Report claims that Adam is ‘Rangers’ engima’, explaining that he is is a brilliant player – who could be a ‘footballing monster’ – but has issues relating to fitness, speed and tracking back.

As made clear by the comments above from Van Bronckhorst, that other side of the game is something Tillman also struggles with and so it’s easy to see why the comparison has been made.

Of course, like Adam,  who ended up at Liverpool eventually, Tillman could reach a high level. Still only 20, he has that experience in Munich under his belt, while he has shown glimpses of his quality with five direct goal contributions in the league this term.

However, if he wants to make it at Rangers first, he may have to improve on his wider game.

1 of 10
carlos-pena-in-mexico-training

How well do you remember where Rangers' signings came in from down the years? Take our quiz to find out! First up, Carlos Pena was the Gers' most expensive arrival during the summer of 2017, but where did he join from?

Share this article