Who’s the better player: Nani or Bale?


Reports suggest that Nani could be on his way to Manchester City in a £40m moveHere’s an interesting question: who would you rather have in your squad: Manchester United’s Nani or Tottenham’s Gareth Bale? Both are wingers experiencing their best seasons yet for their prospective clubs. Both have some claim for Player of the Season (though I would suggest neither deserve it) and both have their best years ahead of them. I don’t think this is an easy decision.

Gareth Bale has been at Tottenham since 2007, but only really rose to prominence over the course of the last couple of seasons. This season, he’s impressed in particular because his performances have come against the likes of Inter Milan and Arsenal – big, heart-on-sleeve performances when fans want to see it most. His skill on the ball, his pace and his accurate finishing have seen him become one of the most sought after players in Europe.

Nani is another player who has developed at an astonishing rate over the course of the last season. Where he had previously been considered a poor-man’s Ronaldo, he has slowly developed into one of the most important players in Manchester United’s midfield. The fact that he’s the Premier League’s top assist-provider speaks for itself. When he adds goals to his game, he’s going to be a real force.

Both are clearly fantastic players, but if you had to pick one, who would it be?

I’m going to say something that may not go down well amongst Spurs fans. I rate Gareth Bale very highly, but I have to say that I think his stature and his ability have been overrated by the British Press following his two great games against Inter. In terms of importance to Tottenham, I’d say that Luka Modric is much more valuable than Bale.

He’s also a little injury-prone and that has a knock-on effect of disrupting the rhythm of his performances, though this is something that will hopefully clear up over time. The fact, is Gareth Bale plays at such a high-intensity, so full on and with such passion that I’m not surprised he picks up the odd injury or three a season.

Nani, like Bale, is a defender’s nightmare – he can go on either foot and has an enviable amount of technique and creativity to go with all his flair. It’s Nani’s creative spirit that tips the scales in his favour for me. Behind all the flair and the play-acting, Nani is a real player and he’s going to keep getting better.

Statistics only tell half the story – of that I’m well aware. But this season Nani has a 25 goals and assists, whilst Gareth Bale has only 8. For all the hype that surrounds Bale, it’s Nani that provides end-product on a weekly basis.

That’s why I’d have Nani in my squad over Gareth Bale. Over to you – what’s your take?

Follow @ThePerfectPass on Twitter for details on all the latest updates and various football-related musings. are seeking new writers to join the team! If you’re passionate about football, drop us a line at “” to learn more.

[bet_365 type=’generic’ size=’468′ af_code=’365_061437′]

Share this article

Editor-in-Chief at ThisisFutbol. Please feel free to get in touch if you have question, queries, comments or just fancy having a rant.

Our email address is:, if you don't fancy getting stuck in in the comment's section.


  • nani de best and desirable player.

  • Lee YL says:


  • john smith says:

    you deluded man utd prick

  • Leigh says:

    As an Evertonian, I am completely objective. Bale is completely overrated in the press, and Nani offers far, far more.

  • Elliot says:

    I think both players will be phenomenal in the next few seasons and I’d happily pick em both, there’s two wingers in a team right! But if I had to pick one I would say Nani and the main reason I swayed this way is because of how ambidextrous and as much as I love Bale, he might as well not have a right foot. Also I think Nani has better technique and delivers “float crosses” rather than “drill crosses” which I think are easier to control. But in Bales defence, although both these players are incredibly fast, Bales pace is on a whole new level to any footballer, and if he goes to a body parts dealer and buys himself a left foot, then he will give Nani a serious RUN for his money 🙂

Comments are closed.