Is it really unthinkable that Liverpool should lose their lynchpin?


Written by James McManus for There appears to be growing cause for concern around Anfield that Pepe Reina may well be the latest star name to leave the club, but is the Spanish goalkeeper irreplaceable?

Well first and foremost, to trot out the tired old cliché and get it out in the open as quickly as possible – ‘no player is bigger than the club’. Of course, if the protracted contract saga involving Wayne Rooney earlier on in this season taught us anything, it was that things are not always as clear cut as this and that sometimes the club has to bend to the player’s will and not the other way around.

Liverpool have suffered over recent seasons with the departures of Xabi Alonso, Javier Mascherano and Fernando Torres all hitting the club hard. To lose Reina though would remove the last bastion of the Rafa Benitez era while simultaneously sounding the death knell to any progress the club may hope to achieve in the near future.

Liverpool are not a club that is in free-fall as such, nor are they a club on the decline; estimations of their demise have been and will continue to be greatly exaggerated in some quarters, but it is clear that they are going through a transitional phase both off and on the pitch, one that will require the patience of both the players and the fans.

Fernando Torres, since his departure, has come out with various diatribes about the chaotic state behind the scenes at Anfield that have proved to be a little too close to the bone for some Liverpool fans. His departure was certainly acrimonious in its nature but Torres has at least been refreshingly honest in his appraisal of the situation describing the reasons for his departure stating:

“In the summer in which Xabi Alonso left, I started to wonder (about leaving). When reinforcements didn’t arrive, I started to wonder if Liverpool were the club it’s history suggests, or if it was in fact a selling club. What other teams could I have gone to? I couldn’t go to Man Utd out of respect for Liverpool. Or Real Madrid because of my past. I don’t think Barcelona needed anyone. I didn’t like the idea of Italy. Chelsea were the only club left, the only option”, he then goes onto add that “the institution was in chaos with the sale. There was all this talk of possible projects. In many ways it reminded me of Atletico Madrid – a great history, many ideas but without money. It needed time. I don’t have that.”

If that last sentence doesn’t send shivers down the most hardened of Liverpool fan’s spines then nothing will. It is clear that NESV are there for the long-haul and that there will be money made for investment in the playing staff should it be asked, but a footballer’s career is only so long and amongst the passion and demand for loyalty from its fans, we can often forget that to most players, this is a career and one in which they will look to get the most out of while they still can. In no other profession is loyalty demanded as readily as it is with footballers.

Pepe Reina has been a loyal and committed player to the club since his arrival in 2005 for £6m from Villarreal, yet the sounds emanating from the Spaniard’s mouth at the moment are most worrying. Reina stated just last week: “It’s not about being patient, it is about the club winning and I want to be competitive. All I can do is train hard and do my best, but who knows what is going to happen here?” Reina’s non-committal stance sounds extremely ominous and it is thought he is waiting to decide on his future in the summer upon learning the future direction of the club and the new owner’s plans for it.

Former Liverpool player Alan Kennedy came out late last week and said that “I’d be amazed if Kenny (Dalglish) thought it would be a good idea to cash in on him (Reina) like he did with Torres, because for me, Pepe is irreplaceable” before rather correctly adding in my view that “any replacement is going to be a step down.”

Click HERE to head to PAGE 2.

[bet_365 type=’generic’ size=’468′ af_code=’365_061437′]

Share this article



  • Blindside says:

    Can I just tell you…..Nobody is irreplaceable! All argument aside after a very long life I can tell you that. If you believe anyone is irreplaceable you have leaned nothing!

  • ShardeYNWALFC4EVER says:

    Everybody can be replaced, Owners, managers, strikers, keepers,journalists!
    The bottom line is if you have fallen out of love you should part company.
    Reina wants CL football, well he should not have scored for Chelskis in the 4-4 draw.
    if your heart & mind is elsewhere you make mistakes, many of them, like HE did against West Ham, three of them.
    There are others out there who would & can lovingly fill the void.
    Long Live LFC, UNWA

  • Mello says:

    It’s almost certain he’ll leave in the summer. Will be a shame but I can’t fault him completely. Hopefully we’ll get a sizable fee that can be used to replace him and patch up a few other positions.

  • Antix1 says:

    @ sharde . UNWA ??? and you call yourself a liverpool supporter… lmao

  • Ste says:

    Look, if he was staying he’d have publicly declared that he was!, therefore he should be dropped, put on the transfer list and sold at the nearest opportunity!.

    NO more Spanish mercenaries!!!.

  • Pooch says:

    For once I would like he club to tell the player (reina if he asks to leave) to turn around, take his agent and return when his contract ends.

    Sorry Pepe, you signed a 6 year contract. Shut your whinging, and get on with it. Only 1 team per year wins the title so you have no guarantees anywhere else. 2 Years and we will be back in the CL. Your a keeper, you have another ten years.

  • Alex says:

    should he want to leave,we want 22million which is his transfer price and off to any team he wants..the club needs hungry players(like Suarez and Carroll) and not bored and overrated player(like Torres and,i hope not,Reina) one is irreplaceable and there are some keepers out there who could do the job:Akinfeev,Lloris,Stekelenburg,Neuer,De Gea,Given,Diego Lopez,Muslera to name a few.My favorite from these is Akinfeev who i rate greatly and is young(24 years old)..but still if Reina is commited and wants to stay,i’d never sell him.
    Johnson Dann Agger Baines
    Young Gerrard Adam Dzsudzsak
    Suarez Carroll

Comments are closed.